CliqueClack TV
TV SHOWS COLUMNS FEATURES CHATS QUESTIONS

NCIS – Who’s Abby without the Sciuto?

How much did Detective Sportelli and Tony remind you of Gibbs and Fornell? I know the whole ex-wife thing is missing as a foundation, but the two were so great together, I couldn’t help but see the similarities!

- Season 9, Episode 4 - "Enemy on the Hill"

After a poor start to the season thus far, NCIS scored a solid “not bad” with last night’s episode. I don’t know that I can point to why I found this week’s case more intriguing than the past few weeks’, but at least I’m able to say that I did, which is a start in the right direction.

I know we’ve met Detective Danny Sportelli (Jack Conley) before, but to be honest his prior appearance does not stand out for me. After this appearance, however, I don’t imagine that I’ll be forgetting him anytime soon. His back-and-forth with Tony was awesome … I hope we haven’t seen the last of their crossover cases.

I was actually curious enough about the mystery surrounding George Kaplan and his accountant Drew Turner (Melissa Ponzio) that I was waiting for the resolution. It didn’t live up to all its early promise, but what can you do. And Navy Lieutenant Commander Geoffrey Brett (Brett Tucker) made his side of the story interesting enough that I didn’t feel the plot sagging in the middle.

What was kind of annoying — and annoyingly cliched — was how convinced Brett was that he couldn’t have been in danger, leading him to push back against the protection that NCIS was offering him. There’s something about TV characters and the threat of danger … everyone thinks they can fend for themselves, and everyone refuses the free professional security that gets offered to them. Why?

Meanwhile, while I understand that a dead hit man isn’t going to stop a determined individual’s agenda, I did wonder why The Cooler’s unfortunate — yet morbidly humorous — demise didn’t convince Gibbs and company that Brett might have at least been temporarily safe from another assassin … it must take time to line the good ones up! It seemed so unlike Gibbs to have not thought that one through, instead rushing ahead with the protection detail.

The other major story of the week was Abby’s. Called upon to donate a kidney — who else thought she’d be donating to The Cooler? — she discovered that she had a brother that she never knew about. Forgetting for a moment that we didn’t know her original brother (it might have been a smart move to establish her family as she knew it before introducing a mystery character to the game board), I kind of wasn’t so interested in her tale. But I know that many of you are … therefore I bring it up.

So because I’m not so curious, I’ll put it to you: what did you think about the personal reveal? Is there, or will there be, a significance to what we’ve learned beyond the fact that the revelation made Abby feel lost? Is she about to embark on an arc that will involve her reaching out to her birth family, trying to reevaluate who she is and what she’s all about? Or was the point really just to reaffirm how much Gibbs cares for her, like so many scenes with so many other members of the team in the past? With McGee’s grandmother already popping up, is this going to be a season with a lot of personal exposition? Personally I’d love that, particularly as it relates to people’s families.

What do you think is ahead? And how are you finding the ninth season so far?

NCIS Grandma McGee: hippie or anarchist? [51eRnHz2DHL. SL160 ] (IMAGE)NCIS Grandma McGee: hippie or anarchist? [517viGC516L. SL160 ] (IMAGE)NCIS Grandma McGee: hippie or anarchist? [51yRekuK3tL. SL160 ] (IMAGE)

Photo Credit: CBS

Categories: | Episode Reviews | Features | General | NCIS | News | TV Shows |

5 Responses to “NCIS – Who’s Abby without the Sciuto?”

October 12, 2011 at 9:13 PM

I didn’t quite care for the Abby adoption angle. At the end of the day, Abby’s still Abby. However, I’m impressed they found an actor who has the same eye color and eye shape as Pauley.

Regarding the hit of the week, I am tired of characters who resist protection. But, this time around, because of his resistance, especially when he locked Ziva out, I assumed that Brett was guilty and put the hit out on himself so he could disappear.

October 15, 2011 at 11:12 PM

I thought Abby’s revelation was awesome and sincerely hope they carry through with this theme. The revelation was done extremely well. As an adoptee who knows several people who were not told as children that they were adopted, it is a very emotional topic and has tremendous potential for intrigue and plot. I did my birth family search and have been told we should be on TV or write a book because of all the coincidences, etc. that occurred in the process. My favorite show and definitely part of “my family” just as they are, no matter whatever the characters’ surnames.

October 17, 2011 at 12:10 AM

Glad you enjoyed (and that you were able to relate)! I’m not an Abby fan, so her stories never grab my attention … but I’m glad they’re connecting with people like you. :)

October 30, 2011 at 9:55 PM

Kind of a lackluster plot, but I felt all the characters were back to form. The killer wistfully brushing his thumb over the Navy insignia on his cover before setting it down on the table was one of those subtle touches I expected from this show in previous seasons.

I remember Sportelli being more belligerent before. It’s nice to see him not having a dog in the fight. And Tony’s cheesy grin was perfect.

Think it through. If Gibbs doesn’t rush a protection detail onto the supposed target, and the Commander gets whacked before he does, he’s going to look incompetent, if not grossly negligent. The situation you’re describing doesn’t have any kind of predictable timetable during which the target can be considered “safe.” If the contract killer fell through, the client might just steal a car and run the Commander over while crossing the street.

I actually felt for Abby in her scenes tonight. That hasn’t always happened with the character development on the show lately.

November 1, 2011 at 2:32 PM

Your scenario makes sense, but I still think Gibbs could have assumed a certain window of time … at the very least enough to set up surveillance on him before protection. If a second assassin needed to get up to speed by observing him first, they could have caught the killer before anything happened.

Powered By OneLink